Four years ago, Asha made what seemed like an impossible decision. She knew the journey from Kenya’s Dadaab refugee camp back to her native Somalia was risky. But after an attack by the Somali Islamist group al-Shabaab, the Kenyan government had threatened to close the vast, sprawling camp for security reasons. Asha feared for her family’s safety if Kenyan soldiers moved in to evict them.

“I wanted to be gone before the rough-up,” recalls Asha. “I didn’t want my girls raped by [the] military forcing them on buses. I wanted to protect myself too.

“We were looking for a way out.”

In Dadaab, all they had was a makeshift shelter on a patch of sandy ground. In an isolated region, there was little opportunity; Asha was tempted by the money they would receive to restart their lives. Under an ongoing voluntary repatriation scheme, the UN refugee agency (UNHCR) was offering returnees about $80 (£62) a person, as well as the first flight of Asha’s life. To Asha and her children, it seemed like a fortune.

However, even going back to a warzone involves greasing some palms, she says . Asha, whose name has been changed at her request for fear of retaliation, claims she had to hand over one family member’s repatriation money to be accepted for return, even though the UNHCR says all services are free. She says she paid it in two instalments: an initial amount at a UNHCR field office, the rest to an interpreter working with the agency.

Asha’s experience is echoed by dozens of refugees who spoke on condition of anonymity for this investigation. They say corruption is endemic in east African refugee camps and implicate both UNHCR staff and employees of partner organisations. Refugees at the camp have fled war or dictatorships in search of security, but many say everything – from gaining refugee status and receiving food rations, to being chosen for resettlement to another country or even repatriation back to a warzone – involves the expectation of a bribe.

The UNHCR denies allegations of widespread corruption.

“The overwhelming majority of our 16,000 personnel are deeply committed professionals, many of whom are working in difficult environments, sometimes risking their own safety,” said the agency in a statement.

“As with other organisations, we are not immune to risk or failure on the part of individuals. This is why we have a solid safeguarding structure, which has been further strengthened in the last two years, and which we continuously seek to improve.”

A refugee walks under a UNHCR awning in Dadaab. Photo by Sally Hayden.

Between 2014 and January 2019, nearly 80,000 refugees returned from Dadaab to Somalia. In the same period, cash grants for returnees rose to between $150 and $230 for every family member – some handed over shortly before departure, the rest following arrival in Somalia.

In March this year, the Kenyan government once again announced it was closing Dadaab, giving the UNHCR a six-month deadline and asking them to “expedite relocation of the refugees and asylum-seekers residing therein”. Somali refugees say they’re certain the announcement will lead to an increase in the exploitation of people deciding to return.

In interviews at the camp in October 2018, 11 refugees alleged that UNHCR staff and people working with them demanded bribes for repatriation of between $20 and $200 a person for a large family.

“If you pay, you’ll go to the top of the list,” says Asha.

“To me it sounds like a curse for an agency worker to take money from a poor refugee going to a warzone,” says a member of the Somali Bantu ethnic group, claiming he knows people who have paid and is considering it himself.

“They charge $20 per person. Once you pay that, you get your name posted,” he says, referring to a list announcing who’s travelling next.

Another mother says refugees even hand over money on the airstrip, right before boarding Somalia-bound planes. A middleman will pretend to escort them, lifting their luggage and taking the cash. If they don’t pay, the middleman will “create chaos,” she says – “[he will] say there’s a problem and bring them back”.

Asked about accusations of bribery in the repatriation programme, UNHCR Dadaab’s repatriation officer Woja Apuuli said he had not heard of this happening, and did not see why it would be necessary. “All services at UNHCR are free of charge,” Apuuli points out.

Boda boda drivers pose in Dadaab refugee camp, eastern Kenya. More than 200,000 refugees live there - mainly Somali. Photo by Sally Hayden

Refugees who witness misconduct can lodge complaints, which are then investigated, says UNHCR spokesperson Cecile Pouilly: “In Kenya, for instance, refugees can report misconduct of any staff member of UNHCR, a partner or a contractor, by email, by filling in a webform, by using complaints boxes that are available at all UNHCR offices or by calling our toll-free helpline.”

Over the past two years, Donald Trump’s travel ban has shut down the possibility of resettlement for Dadaab’s Somali refugees, thousands of whom were in the process of being considered for relocation to the US.

Meanwhile, the World Food Programme has drastically cut rations in Dadaab in recent years, citing insufficient funding. As they grow increasingly desperate, many refugees are entering into debt to feed their families.

“For the last three years, there’s no resettlement [to western countries],” says another single mother. “Repatriation is the most corrupt department, actually.”

Signs placed around Dadaab say: “Return is your choice”. But many refugees feel their days in Kenya are numbered.

“Basically, we are in an open jail,” says one man.

Somali refugees brand a donkey in Dadaab refugee camp, eastern Kenya. Photo by Sally Hayden.

A Bantu refugee who works as a UNHCR contractor says he has reported concerns about exploitation in the repatriation process. “The biggest problem is if you complain to UNHCR about this corruption you will have problems,” he says, adding that refugees worry they’ll be cut off from services.

Asha’s 2015 return to Mogadishu, Somalia’s febrile capital, was short-lived. Within a year of her arrival, she was injured by shrapnel from a bomb that exploded near her house. Like more than 2,000 other refugees in the past five years, the family returned to Dadaab. But the feeling of insecurity there has left them with no hope and no chance for a future.

Seated on a woven mat in the shade beside her shelter, Asha describes how her hungry children only get two meals a day – porridge in the morning and a meagre dinner at night – and says the corruption she has witnessed makes it feel even more unfair. “UNHCR is an international organisation and I fear it’s not aware about this, not fully,” she says. “This is greedy individuals and opportunists who don’t care about human suffering and want to get rich on poor people.”

Asylum for Sale was produced in collaboration with Journalists for Transparency, a project of Transparency International, and 100Reporters, a US-based nonprofit news organisation

MORE FROM THIS ISSUE

The Baltic border loophole in EU’s Russia sanctions

“Back door privatization”? Global South’s Share of Deep-Sea Mining Profits Under Scrutiny

Escaped human trafficker put on Netherlands ‘most wanted’ list

Africa’s Hidden Victims: Pandemic Prompted Surge in Police Brutality

This story is being co-published with 100Reporters

Africa’s Hidden Victims: Pandemic Triggered Hunger, as Food Aid Fell Prey to Power Politics and Corruption

Africa’s Hidden Victims: healthcare Workers Struggled Amid Lack of PPE, Salary Delays and Disappearing Hardship Pay

CORRUPTION AND BLAME GAME STALLS PROGRESS

How did one of North Africa’s biggest smugglers escape prison?

Evidence suggests corruption and police complicity led to the escape of a notorious smuggler accused of transporting, extorting, and imprisoning thousands of migrants.

Outlawed Tradition Returns – Pandemic Property Grab

Coronavirus leaves widows in Zambia homeless, as in-laws claim their homes

As election looms, lack of funding from government at heart of state’s inability to tackle Covid-19

As election looms, lack of funding from government at heart of state’s inability to tackle Covid-19

Who benefits from COVID-19 funding in Myanmar?

Who benefits from COVID-19 funding in Myanmar?

COVID-19 patients asked for “pocket money” at Yangon hospitals

COVID-19 patients asked for “pocket money” at Yangon hospitals

Uber in Kenya: Where Disruption Met Desperation

How a String of Big Promises Led to Shattered Dreams Shifting corporate moves left drivers saddled with debt

Built By Impunity

A J4T Investigation into the record of poor building-code enforcement that’s allowed sub-standard construction in Kenya and Mexico.

UN Refugee Agency reopens corruption investigation in Ugandan camp

UN Refugee Agency reopens corruption investigation in Ugandan camp

Asylum for Sale: UN probe finds Sudan staff member solicited bribes from refugees

An internal UN refugee agency investigation into allegations of corruption in its Sudan resettlement operations.

Asylum for Sale: Male refugees victimized by sexual violence say officials wanted bribes to help

Male refugees victimized by sexual violence say U.N. staffer wanted bribes to help them

Asylum for Sale: Whistleblowers say U.N. refugee agency does not protect us or address corruption

The U.N.'s refugee agency has failed to address corruption or protect whistleblowers.

Trafficking in Impunity

Convicted of Trafficking Women in Nepal, Politician Claims Mistaken Identity. Remarkably, Supreme Court Clears Him of Charges.

In Kenya and Uganda UN caseworkers are demanding bribes from refugees. Fraud and corruption are endemic, those who speak out are punished.

In some of the world's most desperate places, UN caseworkers are demanding bribes from refugees.

Built to Fail: The Ravaged Landscape of Construction Corruption

In Nairobi, images of collapsed apartment and business towers have captured public attention and directed light to a global problem. Poor building-code enforcement has allowed sub-standard construction, with tragic consequences from Nairobi to Mexico City.

Unfair Trade

The goal is considered honorable; consumers appreciate being able to help make life better for farmers and laborers in Africa. But on some farms in Kenya, Ghana and Cameroon, reality among the crops seems quite different.

East Goes West

Dangerous passage and uncertainty in the Mediterranean and Europe push migrants and refugees to the Americas.

Corruption and Poaching: The Tusk at Hand

Poachers' sophisticated network drives trafficking of ivory and horns through East Africa

Egypt’s Young Preservationists Shut Out by Old Guard

How Egypt’s best hopes for the future of its national treasures are shut out by the old guard

SPOILED: Corruption from Farm to Table